Jane
Doe 2003-05-05 1 Signed Hey! No fair! You have to continue. I want to know who's there. Poor Elrohir, he's all abandoned. :( Please get the next part up soon. |
Jane
Doe2 2003-05-06 1 Anonymous Your fic is not terrible, you have a good grasp of grammar and spelling. But, there are some questions to ask yourself: Why did I create this girl? Could I have accomplished the goal of my story without her? Exploring Elrohir's emotions after his mother sailed - that's a very interesting idea... go with that, and try leaving out the random girl? See what you come up with. Don't be afraid to ask for help, people are usually more than willing to give it. And a beta reader might help you, some of your sentences were a little awkward. You have potential. Reach for it. |
John
Doe 2003-05-06 1 Anonymous This is such a piece of crap that you shouldn't be threatening not to post. It would be great if this story didn't go any further, it's gone too far as is. Your OC is a bobby sue or a gary sue. Some would say since it's a son it's orginal story line but it's not. Get a beta and in regards to your 'not going to put up next chapter till I get so many reviews' grow up, you aren't that good of a writer |
Eodred
2003-05-26 2 Anonymous What kind of name is Jen? And how did you even manage to get anyone to put your stories on this website, they are hideously boring, and there is no plot. At least you seem to be sharp enough to get the facts right (for the most part). Oh yeah, by the way, you ought to edit your stories, you're even worse than most people, you use all the wrong words in all the wrong spots. Didn't your parents care enough to send you to school (if you're not sure what I'm talking about, school is a place where you learn)? And Wizards are Istari, not Maia! |
And just so you know, yes, the wizards are Istari AND Maia. This person didn't research far back enough and just made himself look even more stupid. Kudos dude. You're my hero of the day.